So Andy Didn’t Win The US Open, Is That So Bad?

For all you diehard Andy Muray fans, I say buck up. The sun did rise this morning and it will be ok. Ask yourself this question, is Murray losing his first Grand Slam final THAT BAD? As it turns out, no, it isn’t.
I had a little time on my hands (bored) when the action was rained out on Saturday when the semifinals and women’s final should have been played. I thought I would hop in my DeLorean and take a trip back to the start of the Open Era and see how the men fared when they either won or lost their first Slam final. Note that although players like Rod Laver reached, then won, their first Major before the Open Era began, I am including players that did win Majors in the Open Era regardless if their first Slam came before 1968.
Of the 49 men that won Slams in the Open Era, 35 won their first Slam final and 14 didn’t.
For those that lost their first Slam final, first let’s take a look at the names: Rod Laver, John Newcombe, Ivan Llendl and Andre Agassi to name a few, did not win their first Slam. Some like Llendl and Agassi took a few finals before they were able to bag their first major and they each went on to win 8 Slams. Not bad.
Let’s take a further look:
| Player | Runner-Up | Champion | Span From Finalist to Champion | Total Slams |
| Rod Laver | 1959 Wimbledon | 1960 Australian Championships | 2 | 11 |
| Arthur Ashe | 1966 Australian Championships | 1968 U.S. Open | 11 | 3 |
| John Newcombe | 1966 U.S. Open | 1967 Wimbledon | 3 | 7 |
| Stan Smith | 1971 Wimbledon | 1971 U.S. Open | 1 | 2 |
| Manuel Orantes | 1974 French Open | 1975 U.S. Open | 6 | 1 |
| Guillermo Vilas | 1975 French Open | 1977 French Open | 8 | 4 |
| Ivan Llendl | 1981 French Open | 1984 French Open | 12 | 8 |
| Pat Cash | 1987 Australian Open | 1987 Wimbledon | 2 | 1 |
| Andre Agassi | 1990 French Open | 1992 Wimbledon | 9 | 8 |
| Petr Korda | 1992 French Open | 1998 Australian Open | 23 | 1 |
| Carlos Moyà | 1997 Australian Open | 1998 French Open | 5 | 1 |
| Goran Ivanišević | 1992 Wimbledon | 2001 Wimbledon | 36 | 1 |
| Juan Carlos Ferrero | 2002 French Open | 2003 French Open | 4 | 1 |
| Novak Djokovic | 2007 US Open | 2008 Australian Open | 1 | 1 |
Some pretty big names and some pretty good results. Some players like Korda and Ivanisevic won only 1 Slam and had a pretty long stretch between reaching their first final and winning their first title but that’s at the far end.
On average these players won 3.3 Slams and it took them 8.7 Grand Slams from when they reached the finals to when they won their first Major. Of the 14 players in this list, 7 won only one major title. Ferrero and Ivanisevic are pretty safe bets to not win another Slam but I am pretty sure we will be crossing Djokovic off this list soon enough.
Now, if you take off the one Slam wonders, the numbers increase quite a bit. On average, the 7 on the list that did win more than one Slam, won 6.1 Majors and it took them 6.5 Slams to do so. Not bad, not bad at all.
However, if you look at those who did win their first Slam…
| Player | Champion | Total Slams |
| Ken Rosewall | 1953 Australian Championships | 8 |
| Jan Kodes | 1970 French Open | 3 |
| Andres Gimeno | 1972 French Open | 1 |
| Jimmy Conners | 1974 Australian Open | 8 |
| Bjorn Borg | 1974 French Open | 11 |
| Mark Edmondson | 1976 Australian Open | 1 |
| Adriano Panatta | 1976 French Open | 1 |
| Roscoe Tanner | 1977 Australian Open - January | 1 |
| Vitas Gerulaitis | 1977 Australian Open - December | 1 |
| John McEnroe | 1979 US Open | 7 |
| Brian Teacher | 1980 Australian Open | 1 |
| Johan Kriek | 1981 Australian Open | 2 |
| Mats Wilander | 1982 French Open | 7 |
| Yannick Noah | 1983 French Open | 1 |
| Stefan Edberg | 1985 Australian Open | 6 |
| Boris Becker | 1985 Wimbledon | 6 |
| Michael Chang | 1989 French Open | 1 |
| Andrés Gómez | 1990 French Open | 1 |
| Pete Sampras | 1990 US Open | 14 |
| Jim Courier | 1991 French Open | 4 |
| Michael Stich | 1991 Wimbledon | 1 |
| Sergi Bruguera | 1993 French Open | 2 |
| Thomas Muster | 1995 French Open | 1 |
| Yevgeny Kafelnikov | 1996 French Open | 2 |
| Richard Krajicek | 1996 Wimbledon | 1 |
| Gustavo Kuerten | 1997 French Open | 3 |
| Patrick Rafter | 1997 US Open | 2 |
| Marat Safin | 2000 U.S. Open | 2 |
| Lleyton Hewitt | 2001 US Open | 2 |
| Thomas Johansson | 2002 Australian Open | 1 |
| Albert Costa | 2002 French Open | 1 |
| Roger Federer | 2003 Wimbledon | 13 |
| Andy Roddick | 2003 U.S. Open | 1 |
| Gastón Gaudio | 2004 French Open | 1 |
| Rafael Nadal | 2005 French Open | 5 |
Those are some pretty big names. Sampras, Borg, Conners, McEnroe, Federer, Nadal all won their first Slam final. Granted, you get more one Slam wonders in this group like Muster, Gaudio, Chang and others but in total, those 35 men won a total of 124 Slams, an average of 3.5 per player.
If you take away the 16 one Slam wonders the remaining 19 men won 105 Slams, an average of 5.5 per player and of those 19 less than half, only 9, won less than 5 Slams.
So be patient Andy Murray. Newcombe, Llendl, Agassi and Laver all won at least 7 Slams, that’s not bad company to be in.
September 11th, 2008 at 10:45 pm
[...] Links « So Andy Didn’t Win The US Open, Is That So Bad? [...]